Match Play Champions
| Gross Champions | Net Champions (began 2023) |
| 1925 Elizabeth J. Darrow (Kahkwa) | |
| 1926 Louise J. Palmer (Kahkwa) | |
| 1927 Inglis Griswold (Kahkwa) | |
| 1928 Aurelia Englert (Glenwood) | |
| 1929 Louise J. Palmer (Kahkwa) | |
| 1930 Louise J. Palmer (Kahkwa) | |
| 1931 Louise J. Palmer (Kahkwa) | |
| 1932 Louise J. Palmer (Kahkwa) | |
| 1933 Loie Statler (Glenwood) | |
| 1934 Kathryn Miller (Kahkwa) | |
| 1935 Winifred “Sunny” Jardine (Kahkwa) | |
| 1936 Lydia McBrier (Kahkwa) | |
| 1937 Helen Lieby (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1938 Margaret Holtz (Glenwood) | |
| 1939 Lydia McBrier Jarecki (Kahkwa) | |
| 1940 Lydia McBrier Jarecki (Kahkwa) | |
| 1941 Elaine Ghering (Borland) (Culbertson Hills) | |
| 1942 Elaine Ghering (Borland) (Culbertson Hills) | |
| 1943 No Tournament | |
| 1944 Elaine Ghering (Borland) (Culbertson Hills) | |
| 1945 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1946 Aurelia Englert Herrman (Erie) | |
| 1947 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1948 Kathryn Miller (Kahkwa) | |
| 1949 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1950 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1951 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1952 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1953 Mary Ann Roberts (Kahkwa) | |
| 1954 Eleanor Newby (Glenwood) | |
| 1955 Sally Schickler (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1956 Barbara Robinson (Kahkwa) | |
| 1957 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1958 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1959 Mary Ann Roberts Fessler (Kahkwa) | |
| 1960 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1961 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1962 Dale McNamara (Kahkwa) | |
| 1963 Kay Hebert (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1964 Kay Hebert (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1965 Judy Mitchell (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1966 Jean Forsyth (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1967 Kay Hebert (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1968 Judy Mitchell (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1969 Kay Hebert (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1970 Mary Ann Roberts Fessler (Kahkwa) | |
| 1971 Judy Mitchell Meister (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1972 Judy Mitchell Meister (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1973 Sally Schickler (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1974 Joanie Rhodes (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1975 Sandy Johnson (Erie) | |
| 1976 Betty Burke (Lake Shore) | |
| 1977 Betty Burke (Lake Shore) | |
| 1978 Jean Bianco (Erie) | |
| 1979 Turk Hamilton (Wronek) (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1980 Elaine Satyshur (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1981 Turk Hamilton (Wronek) (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1982 Turk Hamilton (Wronek) (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1983 Turk Hamilton (Wronek) (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1984 Turk Hamilton (Wronek) (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1985 Turk Hamilton (Wronek) (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1986 Mary Ann Roberts Fessler (Kahkwa) | |
| 1987 Mary Ann Roberts Fessler (Kahkwa) | |
| 1988 Turk Hamilton (Wronek) (Gospel Hill) | |
| 1989 Maggi Goodall (Kahkwa) | |
| 1990 Erin White (Eastman) (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1991 Carol Maxwell (Lake View) | |
| 1992 Erin White (Eastman) (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1993 Erin White (Eastman) (Lawrence Park) | |
| 1994 Adrienne Boyd (Hassenplug) (Green Meadows) | |
| 1995 Sue Lefaiver (Erie) | |
| 1996 Adrienne Boyd (Hassenplug) (Green Meadows) | |
| 1997 Katie McClellan (Kahkwa) | |
| 1998 Katie McClellan (Kahkwa) | |
| 1999 Becky Berzonski (Lake View) | |
| 2000 Sue Lefaiver (Erie) | |
| 2001 Keri Dugan (Cooney) (Downing) | |
| 2002 Becky Berzonski (Lake View) | |
| 2003 Karen Bukowski (Lake View) | |
| 2004 Natalie Maleno (Lake View) | |
| 2005 Tanica Bell (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2006 Natalie Maleno Washburn (Lake View) | |
| 2007 Ellen Ciacchini (Brock) (Kahkwa) | |
| 2008 Laura Burkholder (Meadville) | |
| 2009 Stephanie Urban (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2010 Kelly Moylan (Lake View) | |
| 2011 Colleen Miller (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2012 Karlie Zabrosky (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2013 Karlie Zabrosky (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2014 Karlie Zabrosky (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2015 Georgia Capotis (Kahkwa) | |
| 2016 Kelly Moylan (Lake View) | |
| 2017 Megan Moylan (Lake View) | |
| 2018 Stephanie Urban (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2019 Stephanie Urban (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2020 Stephanie Urban (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2021 Stephanie Urban (Lawrence Park) | |
| 2022 Anna Swan (Lake View) | |
| 2023 Anna Swan (Lake View) | Darcey Powell |
| 2024 Anna Swan ( Lake View) | |
| 2025 Karlie Chaffee (Zabrowsky)(Lawrence Park) | |
Names appearing in parenthesis after a player’s name is the married name of the player.